Missionaries
Missionaries, and what happens when the mission changes you
We tell mission stories in one direction: someone goes out and changes a place. The harder, more common story is that the place changes the person who went.
The story nobody puts in the newsletter
Daniel Everett went to the Pirahã to translate the gospel and came back without belief. It's easy to file that as a warning. It's more useful as a description of what happens when a certainty meets people who don't share the questions it was built to answer.
He didn't lose faith because the argument went badly. He lost it because his framework stopped fitting what he was looking at.
Why conviction can be brittle
Faith assembled entirely from answers breaks when it meets a question it wasn't issued for. Job 38:1-4 is God's response to a man demanding explanations: not an argument, a horizon. The size of the thing is the answer.
A faith with room for unanswered questions travels better than one without.
What this asks of people who stay home
Support the person, not the performance. Ask returning missionaries what they saw, not just what they accomplished, and don't punish honesty with concern.
Mark 4:26-29 has the seed growing by a process nobody can see. That applies to the mission field and to the missionary.
Common questions
Why do some missionaries lose their faith?
Usually not because of a single argument. Long exposure to a very different world surfaces questions their faith wasn't built to hold, and there's often nobody safe to ask them with.
Does someone losing faith mean the faith was false?
It means the version they carried couldn't hold what they encountered. That's a real and painful thing, and it's a different claim from the faith itself being empty.
Posts on this
The Missionary Who Lost His Faith
Daniel Everett went into the Amazon in 1977 to translate the Bible for the Pirahã. Over twenty years, quietly, he stopped believing in God — and his story has no clean break in it.
Rescuing Others
Grace pulls us out of the water more than once. Jude says it also expects us to go back in for the people still under.
If this is where you are at the moment, subscribe and I'll send new writing as it comes.